среда, 25 марта 2009 г.

Strategic planning workshops in pilot VET schools (2)

by Martin Gibson, Curricula Development Facilitator


This Review provides an update to the review previously carried out on the first series of workshops (February 2009). It should be read in conjunction with that previous review.

As with the first series of workshops, the activities carried out in March were designed to continue towards the original objectives, namely:

• Assist Lyceum/College Directors to develop suitable Strategic Development Plans for the further development of their institutions.
• Support the teams that will be responsible for future development of the VET Institutions.
• Support the further implementation of the project “Social Partnership in VET in Kazakhstan.

WORKSHOPS CARRIED OUT:

LOCATION DATE
Trade and Economy College, Astana To be scheduled
Lyceum 2, Shymkent 17 March 2009 (photos)
Agri-business College, Tulkibas 18 March 2009 (photos from workshop)
Lyceum 4, Astana 24 March 2009


RESULTS

• Further progress was made in developing the strategic development plans and each of the Pilot Centres is now at a stage where it can now develop a set of strategic aims and begin work on strategic objectives.
• Emphasis was placed on the need to undertake regular environmental analysis and stakeholder analysis and to reflect key opportunities and threats in the strategic aims of the institution.
• Links were made to work undertaken by the social partnership expert, Lina Kaminiskiene. In particular use was made of previously produced SWOT analyses and workshop participants were directed to consider the output of their previous SWOT analyses when creating their strategic development plans.
• Each management team has been asked to complete the next stage of their deliberation by April 3rd for translation. This is to include a statement of Mission and Vision, a list of Strategic Aims (5 to 7 ideally) and a set of strategic objectives underpinning one of the strategic aims.



ISSUES

Inevitably the methodology of strategic development planning is raising a number of important issues:

• The language of the hierarchy of aims, goals, objectives, and tasks is unfamiliar to many participants, to some extent based on linguistic differences. Participants do not easily separate these concepts and therefore can begin to confuse broad long term issues with more immediate concerns.
• Systematic strategic planning at the level of the whole organisation appears to be relatively unknown in the 4 institutions. Whilst all the institutions certainly plan for their futures Directors also see their strategic options as relatively constrained due to State control, limited finances, employers reluctant to engage, a legacy of poor training facilities and more recently the effects of the “crisis”. This makes long term organisation wide planning at a strategic level quite difficult for some to accept.
• Unfamiliarity with the overall methodology inevitably creates misunderstandings which need to be confronted. For example, the idea that one needs to involve the entire senior management team in the strategic planning exercise is not yet well understood. Irrespective of whether deputy directors are engaged in resourcing issues, administrative affairs, managing the educational process or whatever it is important from a strategic planning perspective that all should contribute to the planning process. This lack of identification with “organisational planning” may also reflect on the way that management teams have traditionally operated in the 4 centres and elsewhere in Kazakhstan.
• Likewise involving social partners in the planning process when the immediate returns seem so negligible and when there is no clear legal basis for social partner involvement also creates obstacles to the acceptance of the strategic development planning process.
• Managers appear more comfortable considering and discussing “tasks” rather than broad “functions” with strategic outcomes. This may reflect the fact that they often do not have a managerial language and training with which to easily conceptualise these difficult organisational processes. To the extent that this is true it raises questions about the nature and extent of managerial training which should be made available to VET sector managers in the future.

None of these issues is surprising. They are in fact the very reason why some emphasis on strategic development planning is necessary in the first place.

NEXT STAGES

• Trade and Economy college to be priority for workshop2 in May 2009
• Third phase of workshops: May 2009
• Objective to develop the draft strategic development plans to include all strategic objectives
• Encourage delegation and performance review to deputy level.
• Subsequently develop the guidance notes and the recommendations

MDG
24 March 2009